第四章 句子的扩充


第二十一课 WH系疑问句:WH-ECHO-Q-S/INF-WH-Q-S/WH-Q-S/等

 21-1 [WH-回应疑问句(WH-ECHO-Q-S)] 
 当你错过一个句子某些重要部分时,你可能会像以下(2)中的问题(B1 至B5)那样问。
      (1) A : John lost his claim tag. 约翰把它的行李牌票了。
      (2) B1: John lost his claim what? 约翰把他的什么丢了?
          B2: John lost his what? 约翰把他的什么丢了?
          B3: John lost what? 约翰把什么丢了?
          B4: John what? 约翰什么?
          B5: What? 约翰什么?
 句子B1至B5通过用"what"替换没听到的部分而形成。 (Dadada 表示没有听到的部分。)
      (3)  what + [John lost his claim dadada]
                  John lost his claim what?  (B1)
      (4)  what + [John lost his dadada]
                  John lost his what?        (B2)
      (5)  what + [John lost dadada]
                  John lost what?            (B3)
      (6)  what + [John dadada]
                  John what?                 (B4)
      (7)  what + [Dadada]
                  What?                      (B5)
 我们把这些通过S EPD{Wh-Echo-Question}(WH-ECHO-Q) 而形成的句子叫做WH-回应疑问句,即wh-echo-question(WH-ECHO-Q-S) 。因此,
      (8) WH-ECHO-Q  + K-S(含 dadada)
                    WH-ECHO-Q-S(含 "what")
 21-2 [树形图] 
 (3)至(7)的树形图:
      (9)    (John lost his claim what?)
                  WH-ECHO-Q-S
                   /     \
        EPD[WH-ECHO-Q]     K-S
            (what)        (John lost his claim dadada.)

      (10)    (John lost his what?)
                  WH-ECHO-Q-S
                   /     \
        EPD[WH-ECHO-Q]     K-S
            (what)        (John lost his dadada.)

      (11)    (John lost what?)
                  WH-ECHO-Q-S
                   /     \
        EPD[WH-ECHO-Q]     K-S
            (what)        (John lost dadada.)

      (12)    (John what?)
                  WH-ECHO-Q-S
                   /     \
        EPD[WH-ECHO-Q]     K-S
            (what)        (John dadada.)

      (13)    (What?)
                  WH-ECHO-Q-S
                   /     \
        EPD[WH-ECHO-Q]     K-S
            (what)        (Dadada.)
 21-3 [WH-ECHO-Q的操作] 
 这样,造一个WH-ECHO-Q-S:
        <WH-ECHO-Q>
           步骤一:用"what"替换未听到的部分。
           步骤二:在句尾提高音调(说话时);在句尾添加符号“?”(书写时)。
 通常,扩充子WH-ECHO-Q, "what",看起来并不严格要求语法种类。
      (14)  A: Hanako's homesick. 花子想家了。
            B: Hanako's home-what? 花子想什么家了?
 然而,在以下例句中,它看起来确实在努力使自己符合语法。
      (15)  A: Astronomers have discovered some more black holes.
               天文学家已经发现了更多的黑洞。
            B: They've discovered some more whats?  (Quirk, p.836)
               他们已经发现了更多的什么?
      (16)  A: She sat there and ratiocinated.
               她坐在那儿,推论着。
            B: She sat there and whatted?           (Quirk, p.836)
               她坐在那儿,什么着?
 在以下的WH-ECHO-Q, "what"中,看起来需要再加一个步骤,类似于"我--你转换",即"I-You Switch"。
      (17)  A: I lost my claim tag. 我丢了我的行李票了。
            B: You lost your what?/*I lost my what? 你丢了你的什么了?
      (18)  A: Mary hates this garment bag. 玛丽讨厌这个行李包。
            B: Mary hates that what?/*Mary hates this what?
               玛丽讨厌那个什么?
 但是,要注意,(17 )和(18)的B句是从(19a)和(20a)分别转换过来的,而不是(19b) 和(20b)。
      (19)a.  You lost your dadada.
          b.  I lost my dadada.
      (20)a.  Mary hates that dadada.
          b.  Mary hates this dadada.
 21-4 [非正式WH疑问句(INF-WH-Q-S)(i)] 
 当你错过了一些单词/短语,但你已知道他们是事物,人,地方,时间等,你可以用"what", "who(m)", "where", "when"等来询问,如下:
      (21)  A: I've eaten a slug. 我吃了一个鼻涕虫。
            B: You've eaten what/*whom? 你吃了个什么?
      (22)  A: Mary hit John. 玛丽打了约翰。
            B: Mary hit who(m)/*what? 玛丽打了谁?
      (23)  A: His plane was hijacked near Miami.
               他的飞机在迈阿密附近被劫机了。
            B: His plane was hijacked where/*when?
               他的飞机在哪儿被劫机了?
      (24)  A: Napoleon was defeated in 1815.
               拿破仑在1815年被打败了。
            B: Napoleon was defeated when/*where?
               拿破仑什么时候被打败了?
 在(21)中, "what"替换了"something"。同样地,在(22)中,"whom"替换了"someone" ,在(23)中"where"替换了"somewhere", 而在(24)中"when"替换了 "sometime"。
 树形图:
      (25)    (You've eaten what?)
                  INF-WH-Q-S
                  /     \
         EPD[INF-WH-Q]     K-S
            (what)        (You've eaten something)

      (26)    (Mary hit whom?)
                  INF-WH-Q-S
                  /     \
         EPD[INF-WH-Q]     K-S
            (whom)        (Mary hit someone)

      (27)    (His plane was hijacked where?)
                  INF-WH-Q-S
                  /     \
         EPD[INF-WH-Q]     K-S
            (where)       (His plane was hijacked somewhere)

      (28)    (Napoleon was defeated when?)
                  INF-WH-Q-S
                  /     \
         EPD[INF-WH-Q]     K-S
            (when)        (Napoleon was defeated sometime)
 在本书中,我们称这样的句子为非正式wh-疑问句,即informal wh-question(INF-WH-Q-S) ,并称如"what", "who(m)", "where", "when"等句子扩充子为S EPD{Informal Wh-Question}(INF-WH-Q) 。因而,
        <INF-WH-Q>
     步骤一:用"what", "who(m)", "where", "when"等替换相应没听到的部分。
     步骤二:在句尾提高音调(说话时);在句尾添加符号“?”(书写时)

     INF-WH-Q's相对应的“某单词/短语”(some-words/phrases)列表。
      (29)a. what   →  something, etc.
          b. who(m) →  someone, etc.
          c. whose  →  someone's, etc.
          d. where  →  somewhere, etc.
          e. when   →  sometime, etc.
          f. why    →  for some reason, etc.
          g. how    →  somehow, etc.
          h. which   →  one or the other, etc.
          i. how often →  some times, etc.
 
21-5 [非正式WH疑问句(INF-WH-Q-S)(ii)] 
 一个非正式的wh-question(INF-WH-Q-S)不仅可以当句子某部分没听见时使用,也可以当一个句子一开始就不知道某部分时使用。(31)中的A就是一个例子。
      (30)  A: I lost my camera.
            B: You lost what?
      (31)  A: So you lost what?
            B: A camera.
 (33)中的A也是同样的例子。
      (32)  A: I lost it in the subway.
            B: You lost it where?
      (33)  A: So you lost it where?
            B: Gee, I don't know.
 (31A)和(33A)的意思分别与(30B)和(32B)相同。
      (34) what + [You lost something]
                     You lost what?
      (35) where + [You lost it somewhere]
                     You lost it where?
 21-6 [WH疑问句(WH-Q-S)] 
 更常见的是下列问句。
      (36)  What did you lose? 你丢了什么了?
      (37)  Where did you lose it? 你在哪儿丢的?
 我们称这些句子为wh-question(WH-Q-S) S EPD{Wh-Question}WH-Q
 (36)和(37)的树形图:
      (38)    (What did you lose ø ?)
                  WH-Q-S
                /     \
            EPD[WH-Q]   K-S
              (what)  (You lost something)

      (39)    (Where did you lose it ø ?)
                  WH-Q-S
                /     \
            EPD[WH-Q}   K-S
             (where)   (You lost it somewhere)
 句子(36)和(37)生成过程如下。
      (40) what +  [You lost something]
                        ↓ Step 1 (INF-WH-Q)
                   [You lost what?]
                        ↓ Step 2 (Q)
                   [Did you lose what?]
                        ↓ Step 3 (Front Wh-Word)
                   [What did you lose ø ?]

      (41) where +  [You lost it somewhere]
                        ↓ Step 1 (INF-WH-Q)
                    [You lost it where?]
                        ↓ Step 2 (Q)
                    [Did you lose it where?]
                        ↓ Step 3 (Front Wh-Word)
                    [Where did you lose it ø ?]
 其它例句:
      (42)  Whom did they choose ø as president?
             他们选谁当总统了?
      (43)  How much did you pay ø for such a lemon?
             这样的一个瓜你付多少钱?
      (44)  When is she coming back ø? 她什么时候回来? 
      (45)  Why did he think so ø? 他为什么会那样想?
 21-7 [句首的Wh-Words] 
 当wh-word出现在核心句(K-S)的句首时,我们只用第一个步骤。
      (46)  What happened? 发生什么了?
      (47)  Who hit upon the idea first? 谁第一个想出这个主意的?
 (46)和(47)生成过程如下。
      (48)  what +  [Something happened]
                      ↓ Step 1: INF-WH-Q
                     [What happened?]
      (49)  who  +  [Someone hit upon the idea first]
                      ↓ Step 1: INF-WH-Q
                    [Who hit upon the idea first?]
 其它例句:
      (50)  What seems to be the problem? 看起来是什么问题?
      (51)  Who invented the cotton gin? 谁发明的轧棉机?
 最后,扩充子WH-Q引起以下几个步骤。
     <WH-Q>
       步骤一:把INF-WH-Q加到核心句上,包括some-word。
       步骤二:添加Q,但只有当wh-word 不在句首的时候方可。
       步骤三:把wh-word放在前面。( 出现)
 21-8 [WH感叹句(WH-EXCL-S)]   参考25-8
 两个wh-words, "what"和"how",可以产生一个没有{WH-Q}意思的新句子,但有 {Exclamation感叹}的意思。
      (52)  What a cold day it was! 多么冷的天气啊!
      (53)  How happy she is! 她多高兴啊!
 我们称这些句子为wh-exclamation 或者 WH-EXCL-S。这些句子通过S EPD {Wh-Exclamation}WH-EXCL由带有"very"的核心句生成。
      (54) what  +  [It was a very cold day]
                What a cold day it was!
      (55) how  +  [She is very happy]
                How happy she is!
 (52)和(53)的树形图:
      (56)    (What a cold day it was!)
                     WH-EXCL-S
                    /     \
             EPD[WH-EXCL]   K-S
                (what)    (It was a very cold day)

      (57)    (How happy she is!)
                     WH-EXCL-S
                    /     \
             EPD[WH-EXCL]   K-S
                (how)     (She is very happy)

Copyright(C) 2004 Masaya Oba.
All rights reserved.